UPDATE 12-19-08—USMC Expansion of Twenty-Nine Palms Marine Base—Johnson Valley, the Hammers!!!
By Ed Hills
High Country Off Roaders
Rancho
Cucamonga, CA
12/19/08
Ed has given his permission for this article to be used, forwarded, circulated, etc. Please take action
now!
The time period allotted for public comment to the BLM has expired as of Monday Dec. 15, 2008. From this time forward all comments
should be directed to the USMC specifically regarding the six proposed alternatives for expansion of the Twenty Nine Palms base. In
a nutshell the six alternatives include the following...
There are four alternatives proposed to expand west into, most of if not all
of, Johnson Valley OHV area. These are not acceptable alternatives for the off-road community.
One alternative proposes to expand east
of the existing base. This is the best alternative for the OHV community.
The final alternative is a proposal of no action. We would
not be having this conversation if this alternative was considered to be a reality!
Public comments to the USMC are due by Jan. 31,
2009! I have been informed that the letter generator may continue to be used for this purpose... http://www.pirate4x4.com/letters/
You
may print and mail your comments directly to the USMC also...http://pfjv.org/Mcom.pdf
If this is your first time visiting this post
please read on and participate in BUILDING THE SURGE...
Have we already lost the effort to keep Johnson Valley open to public recreation?
Some of the signs are indeed troubling. At Monday night's meeting of Friends of Johnson Valley it was revealed that only 800 responses
to public comment have been filed with the BLM. The letter generator on Pirate 4x4’s forum has registered only 581 visits. Compare
this to the 20,011 visits logged to the “picture post.” Comparatively, the “picture post’ has had 3400 percent more activity than
the effort to maintain access to one of the most coveted destinations in the country. What are we doing wrong?
Allow me to put forth
some suggestions. We seem to be approaching this latest crisis in our traditional failed form by waging a fight. What’s the problem
you ask? In a fight you react by instinct, to some extent withdrawing to a position of defense. Passion and fear blind you, resulting
in missed opportunities. In a fight there is a winner and a loser. A fight is tiring and grows wearisome over the long haul. This
was plainly evident at the meeting Monday night as told by the faces and look of exhaustion by some present. If we continue in this
manner who do you think will win the fight? The United States Marine Corp or the Off Road Community. We need to find a solution to
satisfy both parties.
I propose we continue from this point forward not in fight mode, but rather in a campaign. What’s the difference?
A campaign is a well thought strategy executed by a team of individuals with conviction. In a campaign you proceed with your eyes
wide open, seizing not only the opportunities that are readily recognized, but also creating new ones. A campaign moves forward in
constant motion with a cohesive message carried out on the ground by people of conviction in their beliefs. Who are these people?
If you are under the impression that there is an organization or coalition fighting on your behalf without your involvement you are
grossly mistaken! If you believe that the so-called leadership in the Off Road community can successfully maintain your right to recreate
in Johnson Valley you are flat out wrong!
You are the coalition. You are the leadership. Each individual is an equal stakeholder in
this process. Remember, we live in a nation governed through democracy. Our military is civilian led by a duly elected Commander-in-Chief.
Government does not exist to empower the people, but rather, people empower the government. Our Campaign to maintain access to Johnson
Valley is critically dependent on your voice. Let’s lay out a strategy to succeed.
We can take a lesson from our own military. Our
Nation’s military has successfully turned around the war in Iraq as a result of a well thought out and multi dimensional campaign,
commonly referred to as The Surge. Among the techniques utilized in the surge was to build relationships with Iraqi citizens. To educate
and gain the assistance of the average person. We need to do likewise. We need to reach out to every off-road enthusiast, regardless
of whether they recreate in JV or not. Also, our military commanders engaged in dialog, building trust and relationships with Tribal
Sheiks. Likewise we need to reach out to Land Managers and Military leaders to share with them the intrinsic value that Johnson Valley represents
to families throughout California and the nation. Currently that value does not appear on any document or form referenced by our government.
Finally we need the surge of troops to make this happen. The military could not have achieved success without committing the boots
on the ground. In this campaign we are all the boots. We all have an opportunity to rise to leadership! Contact your friends, the
companies with whom you do business, exploit every opportunity. There is no master list being utilized to get the word out. You each
have a list in your computer’s address book. Raise awareness! Share knowledge! The technology is at your fingertips.
The expansion
of the 29 Palms base is a benefit to the security of the entire United States, and indeed the free world. Yet it is only the off-road
enthusiast who is being asked to sacrifice. Below are targeted talking/bullet points for you to address in your public comments. Write
a comment regarding each, submit each one separately... one a day, or in one letter. Be creative and think of your own comments. Become
active in the process; engage in the conflict, SURGE towards success. Do three things. First...Bump this to the top. Don’t waste your
time commenting or replying, just bump to the top and spend your time productively submitting your comments. Also, cross post to other
popular forums. Second...Forward a link of this page to everyone you know who recreates off-road. Build the surge. Encourage them
to act. Public comments to the USMC are due by Jan 31, 2009.
1. The landmass
of Johnson Valley totals nearly 200,000 acres. It is the largest designated OHV area in the country. The impact of its closure would
adversely impact the already limited resources available to off-road enthusiasts in the region.
2. The closure would negatively impact
remaining OHV areas both in regards to the environment as well as personal safety as a result of increased and heavily concentrated
use. Injury and even death will likely increase from over population of other BLM and Forest Service managed lands in the future should
the base extend into Johnson Valley.
3. Increased use of Federal, State, and Local public lands will put additional pressure on land
managers resulting in greater restriction to motorized recreation. The result of concentrated use will create increased environmental
concerns likely leading to further closures in the future, thus compounding the problem.
4. In the San Bernardino County portion of
the Mojave Desert the military currently utilizes areas of Federal land for China Lake Naval Weapons Center, Fort Irwin National Training
Center, Twenty Nine Palms Marine Corp Air Ground Combat Center, and a portion of Edwards Air Force Base. This, in addition to countless
Wilderness designated areas already severely restricting public motorized access on public lands. Other western States with similar
topography should be studied.
5. The USMC should study cooperative use of existing military bases to accommodate their training goals.
The USMC has indicated in the scoping meeting that training exercises would be held only once or twice each year. China Lake and Fort
Irwin are directly adjacent to each other. It seems reasonable that cooperative use can be an option. After all mobilization is also
a part of training.
6. Expansion to the east would only require de-designation of a small portion of the Sheephole Valley Wilderness.
Although political leaders have shown resistance to the idea, military training is a benefit to the entire Nation and the responsibility
should be shared equitably among all Americans, not just off-road enthusiast. The number of designated wilderness areas far outnumbers
designated OHV areas in the Mojave Desert.
7. Once used for live military fire, Johnson Valley would become an area restricted and
off-limits to future generations in perpetuity, regardless if the needs of the USMC change and diminish in the future.
8. The characteristics
that define the Hammer trails in Johnson Valley exist nowhere else inside the state of California. For the countless off-road enthusiasts
who have invested thousands into their vehicles for the specific purpose of traversing these trails there is no alternative available
in other Federally managed lands within the Mojave Desert. This represents a potential loss in the hundreds of thousands of dollars
to families and individuals.
Link to USMC comment form, print and send...http://pfjv.org/Mcom.pdf
For additional information regarding
the 6 USMC proposed alternatives visit... http://www.pfjv.org/
ABOVE ALL, IN YOUR COMMENTS, PLEASE BE POLITE. GIVE YOUR NAME/ORGANIZATION,
ADDRESS, PHONE #.